My! Such rhetoric and noise has cropped up around this subject! Not a day goes by without some headline that states something about the state of health care in the USA. Granted, I’m sure the media companies love it, but I’m not sure the public isn’t being done a disservice by this much coverage.
As with any important issue the more noise there is, the less likely it is those who need to know about the issue will actually know enough factual information to develop a good, well reasoned position on the issue. We have had people literally screaming at “town hall” meetings that their health care shouldn’t change. I’ve seen talk about “death squads” on web reports and heard the same on conservative radio shows. I’ve seen people across all political spectrums state that we shouldn’t be messing with the system in ways some suggest we should.
What I’ve seen little of is: agreement. What I’ve heard little of is: constructive ways we can discuss the issue like adults. What I’ve read little of is: acknowledgements that someone is trying to address a system that is and has been broken for a long time.
Really, most of what I’ve experienced is nothing more than hyperbole and rhetoric and these, by their very nature, are not conducive to creating a good solution to the problem. No. Hyperbole and rhetoric serve to do nothing more than: worry people that need nothing more to be worried about, frustrate those that really are trying to find a solution, turn-off those that may have been able to suggest ways we can achieve something better and deflate those that don’t have the good fortune to have a health plan that doesn’t cost them more than their food for the month!
What do I want? Read further . . .
I want these hyperbole/rhetoric spewers to shut up! If your opinion is so “out there” that you must scream to get others to hear and understand you, then your opinion is very likely not of the mainstream. Shut up and let those that are ready to talk and negotiate constructively work on the right solution. If you find hyperbole is where you are most comfortable writing your article for MSN or USA Today – hold your pen/word processor! You, yes YOU are much a part of this problem and you are only serving yourself by continuing your BS. Why not research the issue and present fact-by-fact information that might help your readers understand the issue? Your opinion, while important to you, is not important or helpful to solving this issue.
I want those that really do have good constructive input to provide it to the right people. Can we say representatives and congress folks people? Why are so many of us loathe to contact our legislators???? THIS IS WHAT THEY ARE THERE FOR PEOPLE! Don’t say: “They never will read my e-mail.” This isn’t true. They have staffs that are assigned to do this. The will read it. But what they will not promise to do is vote the way you tell them to. They may not even respond to your note. But they will read it. If you have a suggestion – SEND IT. It just may be the thing your legislator needs to start a constructive discussion.
I want the rich, that frankly have had a super easy ride the last 8 years, to look at their rate of taxation as compared to the rates of taxation in other countries. You have more. You should be willing to support more – and this is coming from someone that is moderately well off, thank you. One only need look at: http://www.taxfoundation.org/news/show/250.html to see the top 1% of the wage earners in the US pay 40.4% of individual income taxes. Sounds high doesn’t it? Consider this though: the minimum AGI one must have to break into the top 1% of earners in the US is just above $410,000/yr. At the US’ highest nominal tax rate (35%) this would mean these folks have $266,500 left over to spend not considering other deductions like Social Security and other hits to income ($410,000*.65 = $266,500). Even if the other hits took out $66,500, the person would still have $200,000 to spend as they please. Remember, this is ANNUALLY and it is the MINIMUM needed to hit the top 1% of earners. Doesn’t sound so bad any more does it? Also remember these are the folks that have accountants that likely find ways to further decrease the amount of taxes these folks are paying. So it is very likely they are actually paying 25% or less in taxes. Lastly, please don’t tell me taxing the rich would affect the amount being “reinvested” in the country. The last year of stock market performance shows these “reinvestors” will pull their investment out so fast it likely will make the markets to “fall down - go boom.” To the rich in the US: Stop whining and enjoy the fact that you have fared better than 99% of the people you see in your every day life. Pay a little extra to build a good health care system.
I want the insurance companies to VOLUNTARILY abstain from lobbying their legislators on this subject! There is no other industry that is more detrimental to providing good health care for everyone. When the conservatives of the country started talking about “death squads” I couldn’t help but roll my eyes and chuckle. Time and again the insurance companies REFUSED to pay for treatments that could have been the difference between life and death for a patient. They had loop-holes in their policies that allowed them to refuse payment. I don’t see how this isn’t exactly the same thing. The result was the same thing . . . they just let the person die. I’m not talking morals, I’m pointing out that we already have a form of death squad, so why are we worrying about another one?
I want us to come to a solution that we all can be proud of and that will move us toward a better healthcare system.
The real crime in this scenario is the fact that many forgo treatment because they can’t afford it and in some cases skipping the treatment or drug can decrease life span. My own parents are a case in point. Recently, my mother, who for years has had severe issues with the nerves and muscles in her body, fell and hit her head because she thought my father had a hold on her. Once my dad realized my mother had fallen, he rallied my brother and they both were able to get her into the bed. (Yes, they moved her. I know – bad idea. They have since been coached to do otherwise.) In the mean time she was bleeding from where she hit her head and was having waves of pain running through her body from the fall. It was then my brother an father started arguing over whether an ambulance should be called! Why the argument? Dad’s insurance doesn’t cover the ambulance call and he thought he could avoid paying the fee by taking her to the hospital himself – if he and my brother could get her out to the car. I don’t blame my father - limited funds require you think this way all the time. I’m very thankful he thought this way when I was growing up. But when it had to do with the health of the family, I wish the situation would have allowed otherwise.
Let’s review: mom falls, hits her head and bleeds from the site, hurts her hip and is yelling in pain each time she moves and dad is considering finances. What is wrong with this picture? There is a lot wrong with this picture! If we truly had a health care system that worked, the cost of an ambulance call wouldn’t even enter dad’s mind. This is a guy that served his country and worked very, very hard in a factory until he retired and now he gets to wonder whether he should call an ambulance when his betrothed is in pain. Wrong, wrong, wrong! How can we treat those that helped build this country this way? THIS is what tells me we MUST reform health care. No argument will sway me otherwise. (They did eventually call an ambulance after my brother called me and I told them to call because they didn’t know what mom might have hurt. Mom got stitches in her scalp and apparently wrenched her hip joint really well – but did not crack her pelvis. She seems to be on the mend now)
While I despise the thought of government run health care – the US government does very little well and those things that it does do, it does at such an expense we should constantly look at ways to insert efficiency into the process, I cannot get around the fact that our health care system doesn’t work well for all of our citizens. Don’t get me wrong, big government is not something I’m a fan of by any means. But, I cannot stand idly by nor can I say that if I happen to earn more than others that I shouldn’t pay more into the efforts to bring all good, comprehensive health care. Right now, not everyone gets the health care they need and that is not the way I want my country to treat its poor, elderly or veterans. We can and should do better.